Our Black female had a yellow dad and the stud dog also had yellow, so she did have yellow and black pups, the chocolate one we mated with the same stud as he is such a wonderful and healthy dog, she had all black to our surprise so this time we have mated her to a chocolate male and fingers crossed we should get chocolate, she happens to be an excellent gun dog that is admired buy a few gun people, the stud is also a gun dog so we aim to train a pup up from scratch ...they are so easy to train, the hardest thing and I must admit I have not pursued it for a while is the stay put command, they tend to come back to me all the time!! I love to see working dogs!